Wednesday, June 17, 2009

The effect of foreclosures on house prices

Most of the economies in the world are facing a serious challenge in the history. Real estate market's meltdown in the US is partly blamed for the current economic crisis. Housing crisis starts with declining housing prices in the US. Although, the housing prices starts declining from the early 2006, the problem exasperated in the second quarter of 2008 when housing prices dropped substantially. House prices fall is continuous and the housing market has not experienced any stability yet. Substantial drop in housing prices has caused significant increase in foreclosures around the country. There are several factors contributing to the collapse of housing price including size, age, noise, different features of the property. There is a widespread concern about the impact of the foreclosed house on housing price in the neighborhood. There is also a general consensus among common people that foreclosed housed are cheaper to comparable properties. In this context, this study investigates if there exists relationship between housing price and foreclosures. Are foreclosed properties underpriced to comparable properties?

The purpose of this study is to examine the influence of foreclosures on housing prices of the area near the Dallas Forth Worth International Airport. This study focuses on measuring the effects of foreclosures on house prices. Are foreclosed properties are undervalued? This paper investigates this question within a dynamic model that addresses the other factors influencing house prices. There are enough evidences that there are market wide systematic effects on housing prices. In this context, this study explores the other factors other than market conditions and the local economy in this model. This study develops a dynamic model of house market at a local level to estimate the influence of foreclosures on house price. House price is a function of several other factors. Therefore, this study concentrates to same local area which share common characteristics. Modeling housing market at the local area with common characteristics is expected to be helpful in identifying the relation between foreclosures and house price. In other words, the study on the factor affecting house prices at a local level will improve empirical finding which helps to gauge the effect of foreclosures on house price.

This study is organized as follows. Section II reviews the existing literature on the relationships among foreclosures, home prices, and other housing variables. Section III provides the detail information about the sample source and selection process, variables used in this study, estimation techniques employed. Section IV presents the estimation results of the study. This section also includes results of several robustness tests. Finally, Section V concludes the finding of the study.

1 comment:

Dr. Hansz said...

Do-able. Foreclosure sales are clearly identified in the MLS data and there are certainly plenty to examine.

Two particular challenges in this study
1. Foreclosure sales have been concentrated in the lower end of the housing market (subprime market). Foreclosure as getting to be a problem in the mid and upper level of the housing market but you have to build your model very carefully to make sure F or foreclosure is just not a proxy for lower sale prices.
2. Along the same lines, foreclosure properties are usually in inferior condition, often in very neglected or rough shape. We use property AGE as a proxy for condition but it is definitely not perfect. The point here is that you will probably find a significant discount for foreclosure sales but you have to be careful to not confound "foreclosure" status with inferior or poor conditions or just lower sale prices in general (back to point 1).

Despite the issues here, a very timely topic.